NEW DELHI [Maha Media]: Yet another controversy arose in US-Iran relations, this time on the planned 'execution' of eight women and subsequent stopping (of the executions) after US President Donald Trump’s appeal to Iranian authorities that their lives be spared. While Trump announced that the eight Iranian women who were to be 'executed' for participating in January protests, would not be 'killed now,' Iran's judiciary denied Trump’s claims calling them "fake news" and a 'fabrication.'
Iranian judiciary, through its official news outlet Mizan Online, said none of the women mentioned in Trump’s posts were ever slated for execution or faced death penalty.
Mizan reported that some of the individuals had already been released, while others were facing charges that would lead to imprisonment, not execution. The outlet accused Trump of being "misled" by unverified social media claims from activists.
It said Trump was "fabricating achievements" to hide a lack of progress in actual negotiations.
The Iranian response was triggered after Trump, on his social media platform on April 22 late night, claimed he had been informed that the executions were cancelled at his request and that four women would be released immediately and other four would face one-month imprisonment.
Iranian officials dismissed this entire narrative as a lie intended to "save face."
'Very good news! I have just been informed that the eight women protestors who were going to be executed tonight in Iran will no longer be killed. Four will be released immediately, and four will be sentenced to one month in prison,' Trump had announced on his social media platform late Wednesday night.
He had earlier on Wednesday morning called for the release of the eight women and said their release would be a great start to peace negotiations.
Trump framed his request as a diplomatic gesture ahead of any planned peace negotiations with Iran.
'To the Iranian leaders, who will soon be in negotiations with my representatives: I would greatly appreciate the release of these women. I am sure they will respect the fact that you did so. Please do them no harm! Would be a great start to our negotiations,' Trump said on his social media platform.
Trump also shared a screenshot of their pictures, originally posted on X by activist Eyal Yakoby. However, the names and identities of all eight women were not disclosed, even though their photographs were shared.
The women were reportedly facing execution for their involvement in the January 2026 protests or on suspicion of aiding the enemy during the ongoing conflict.
Iranian authorities had not officially confirmed the specific execution plans for these eight women.
The photographs of the eight women shared by Trump have become a subject of intense dispute, with the Iranian government labelling them as AI-generated.
However, activists and human rights groups have identified them as real individuals arrested during anti-government protests in early 2026.
Despite denials by Iran government, prominent activists like Masih Alinejad and organizations like the Abdorrahman Boroumand Center maintain that the photos represent real detainees. For example, one of the women was reportedly seen in a state television broadcast being interrogated by the Chief of Judiciary.
The eight women have been identified as: Bita Hemmati and Diana Taherabadi (16), both detained following January protests, Mahboubeh Shabani (32), accused of transporting protesters, Ensieh Nejati, a Kurdish activist allegedly sentenced to death, Golnaz Naraghi (37), a medical professional detained during protests, Venus Hossein Nejad, reportedly coerced into a televised confession, Ghazal Ghalandari and Panah Movahedi, identified by advocacy groups as detainees.
In his late night post, Trump appreciated Iran’s gesture, saying 'I very much appreciate that Iran, and its leaders, respected my request, as President of the United States, and terminated the planned execution.'
'To the Iranian leaders, who will soon be in negotiations with my representatives: I would greatly appreciate the release of these women,' Trump had said in the morning while calling for their release.
'Please do them no harm! Would be a great start to our negotiations,' Trump said.
While the Iranian judiciary maintains that these reports are false, human rights groups have noted that at least one woman arrested during recent protests, has indeed been sentenced to death, though not necessarily the specific individual in Trump's post.